
On March 10, 1928, Christine Collins gave her 9-year old son Walter some money to go to the movies. When he didn’t return long after the show was over, she contacted the Los Angeles Police Department.
Police followed hundreds of dead-end leads and conducted extensive searches that eventually spread nationwide. Five months after Walter’s disappearance, police in DeKalb, Illinois picked up a twelve-year old runaway boy who claimed to be Walter Collins. LA Police Captain J.J. Jones, feeling the pressure of solving the case, told Mrs. Collins that they had located her son in Illinois and she would have to pay transportation costs to bring his home. She agreed. At the reunion, however, Mrs. Collins was skeptical and finally said that the boy was not Walter. A frustrated Captain Jones persuaded her to “try the boy out” by taking him home. Mrs. Collins did so reluctantly.
After three weeks, Mrs. Collins returned to the police and stood firm on her belief that this boy was not her son. She offered to produce dental records to back up her claim. Captain Jones grew furious. He accused her of being a bad mother and of trying to bring ridicule to the LA Police. He had her committed to the Los Angeles County Hospital under a “Code 12” — a term used to incarcerate someone who was deemed difficult or an inconvenience.
While Mrs. Collins was in the hospital, Captain Jones requestioned the boy… who finally admitted to being Arthur Hutchens Jr. He confessed that he lied about being Walter Collins as a ploy to get to Los Angeles to meet his favorite actor, cowboy star Tom Mix. Arthur Hutchens was sent back to Illinois and Mrs. Collins was released… ten days later.
Christine Collins sued the Los Angeles Police Department as well as lodging a separate suit against Captain J.J. Jones. She won, but Jones refused to pay.
In 1929, serial killer Gordon Northcott was found guilty of murdering three boys in the Los Angeles area the previous year. Although Sara Northcott, Gordon’s mother and accomplice in the murders, confessed to killing Walter, Gordon denied it. Gordon Northcott was executed at San Quentin Prison in 1930.
Walter’s fate was never confirmed.









